Part 1
At best, college is an over-priced live-in book club.
At worst, college is an implicit un-American caste system.
All fields are best learned at work from managers and co-workers and by doing and reading.
Even with medicine, key learning is done during the residency after med school.
Part 2
Google Gemini comments:
That is a provocative and increasingly common sentiment. It cuts right to the heart of the current crisis in higher education: the widening gap between cost and perceived value.
Your statement breaks down the problem into two distinct critiques: one economic/functional (the “Book Club”) and one sociopolitical (the “Caste System”). Here are my thoughts on why that perspective resonates so strongly right now, along with the nuances that complicate the picture.
1. The “Over-Priced Book Club” Argument
This critique attacks the educational utility of college. In the age of the internet, information is free. If the primary value of college is simply access to knowledge, the business model is obsolete.
The Autodidact’s Reality: You can buy the syllabus of a Harvard course on Amazon for $200. You can watch lectures from MIT professors on YouTube for free. If college is just about reading books and hearing people talk, the markup is unjustifiable.
The “Veblen Good” Problem: For many, tuition prices have risen not because the product is better, but because high prices signal prestige. When you pay $60,000 a year, you aren’t paying for the books; you are paying for the brand on the diploma.
The Lack of Rigor: There is legitimate criticism regarding grade inflation and the lowering of academic standards to treat students as “customers” rather than learners. If the intellectual friction is removed, it really does become just a social club where you read occasionally.
2. The “Implicit Un-American Caste System” Argument
This critique attacks the societal role of college. The American ideal is meritocracy—that anyone can rise based on ability and hard work. The argument here is that college has become a gatekeeper that protects the status quo rather than disrupting it.
Credentialism as a Barrier: Many entry-level jobs now require a bachelor’s degree for roles that previously did not, essentially barring capable workers who couldn’t afford college. This creates a “paper ceiling.”
The Debt Trap: For the wealthy, college is an investment paid for upfront. For the poor and middle class, it is a debt sentence. When a student graduates with $100,000 in loans, they are economically crippled compared to their wealthy peers, reinforcing class stratification.
Legacy and Access: Mechanisms like legacy admissions or the ability to pay for expensive test prep/tutors suggest that the system is rigged to keep the elite inside the castle and everyone else outside.
The Counter-Perspective: What Are You Actually Buying?
While your assessment is sharp, there are reasons the system persists that go beyond just a scam or a caste system. If we steelman the argument for college, it usually relies on three things that a “book club” cannot provide:
The Signal: To an employer, a degree proves you can stick with a boring, difficult task for four years and navigate a bureaucracy. It is an expensive signaling mechanism for conscientiousness and conformity.
The Network: At elite levels, you aren’t paying for the classes; you are paying for the classmates. You are paying to be in the room with the future founders, CEOs, and leaders. This is arguably part of the “caste system,” but it provides immense tangible value to the individual.
Structured Accreditation: In fields like engineering, nursing, or law, you need verified, standardized training. You cannot “book club” your way into being a structural engineer—or at least, society doesn’t trust you to.
The Verdict
You are hitting on a shift in the cultural zeitgeist. For decades, college was viewed as the “Great Equalizer.” Today, the data suggests it often functions as the “Great Sorter,” separating those with capital (social and financial) from those without.
At its best: It is an incubator for critical thought, social mobility, and deep research that cannot happen in isolation.
At its worst: You are absolutely right—it is a predatory financial product that sells a dream of mobility while delivering a reality of servitude to debt.
Originally posted on X: @EducatedinLaw

