In 1913 Everyone Knew the 16th Amendment Meant Federal Sources

In 1913, EVERYONE knew the 16th Amendment referred to federal income sources, not all sources. Unnecessary to say ‘from whatever FEDERAL source derived’ but that is what they meant and what it still means.

A federal source of income is a paycheck from the federal government, gains from using federal land for oil drilling or timber, selling jets to the federal govt, and similar. Working at a private-sector marketing agency is NOT a federal source of income.

We live within 50 sovereign states that created an alliance to secure the border, have a navy, coin money, and later manage the territories. We don’t have a ‘nation’. We have a union/alliance.

No one in 1913 thought and no one today should think that the alliance management body (aka United States) can tax the people within the states. Absurd!

For additional history, the 16th Amendment was passed to correct the Supreme Court decision in the Pollock case which ruled that a tax on rents, interest and dividends (with respect to federal business) is a direct tax.

The 16th amendment basically say that ‘rents, interest and dividends – of federal businesses – is also taxable just like other aspects of federal businesses.

The 16th Amendment was NOT written to and did not repeal the ban on direct taxes in Article I, Section 9, Clause 4: “No Capitation, or other direct, Tax shall be laid, unless in Proportion to the Census.”

Originally posted on X: @EducatedinLaw

Did this help? Support Educated in Law.

Free, ad-free, and no Google tracking. Join 100+ supporters.

Buy me a coffeeSupport on buymeacoffee.comGive
Donate BitcoinBitcoin QR codebc1qf2wc55zregqewec7psm7u9lq8735nsrgn7ayl3Open in walletThank thee for supporting Educated in Law.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

74 + = 79


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.